Sunday, November 10, 2019
Emily Dickinson Essay
Emily Dickinsonââ¬â¢s place in history has affected many aspects of social order. Dickinsonââ¬â¢s writing touched on many issues that were very important to the life and development of Dickinsonââ¬â¢s persona; such as religion, war, psychosis, and love. Dickinsonââ¬â¢s insight into these issues has been the source of the majority of the interest in her work. Emily Dickenson, throughout her life, sought a personal understanding of God and his place within her life. Her place within the Calvinist Puritan Amherst, however, would not allow for her inquiry into the understanding of the nature of God other than within their specific doctrine. In her childhood Emily Dickenson was shy and already different from the others. Like all the Dickinson children, male or female, Emily was sent for formal education to Amherst Academy. Dickenson began to develop into a free willed person. Many of her friends had converted to Christianity, and her family was also exerting enormous amount of pressure on her to convert. Her father, along with the rest of the family, had become Christians and she alone decided to rebel against that and reject the Church. She had rejected the traditional views in life and adopted the new transcendental outlook. Dickensonââ¬â¢s questioning about God began at an early age. ââ¬Å"Once (to Higginson) she recorded another bit of mystification at adult behaviorâ⬠. (Sewell 326) As Sewell recounts, Dickinsonââ¬â¢s reservations about the nature of God began as early as her genius. As a child, we are told Dickenson felt a disturbance in the speech of a clergyman during as funeral. ââ¬Å"[She was] disturbed by the clergymanââ¬â¢s question, ââ¬ËIs the Arm of the Lord shortened that it cannot save? ââ¬â¢Ã¢â¬ (Sewell 326) Dickinsonââ¬â¢s poetry is a window into her quest for this understanding. In poem number 1241, Dickinson concentrates on nature and its relativity to science. Dickinson looks upon a lilac in the late light of a setting sun. Set on a hill, it receives the last light of day, and subsequently, is the last thing that God sees of that day. The sun is given the action of intending the lilac to be meant for ââ¬Å"Contemplation ââ¬â not to Touchâ⬠. I think this is an allusion to the Calvinist ideal of seeking God through action. Dickinson felt that the actions of the church that surrounded her were hollow and led one no closer to understanding the true nature of God than she had attained in her poetic questionings. The flower is given, above humanity, the focus of Godââ¬â¢s eye. ââ¬Å"The scientist of Faithâ⬠that Dickinson speaks of in this poem is denied any furthering of his understanding when she says: ââ¬Å"His research has but just begun ââ¬â / Above his synthesis / The Flora unimpeachable / To Timeââ¬â¢s Analysisââ¬â¢Ã¢â¬â¢. Here, Dickinson is saying that it is not through active searching that one will find the true nature of God, but in the witnessing of His actionsââ¬âsuch as the creation of lilacs. She ends the poem with the line ââ¬Å"Eye hath not seenâ⬠may possibly / Be current with the blind / But let not Revelation / By theses be detainedâ⬠. This tells the reader that Dickinson felt that the active search for God, (with the eye) will fail. However, the ââ¬Å"blindâ⬠will not have their revelations detained. In the poem #564 Dickinson centers on the physical building of churches as a problem with her understanding of God. Within this poem Dickinson tells the reader that the deification of the man made houses of worship also distract from oneââ¬â¢s understanding of God. The line ââ¬Å"God grows aboveââ¬âso those who pray / Horizonsââ¬âmust ascendâ⬠illustrates Dickinsonââ¬â¢s idea that limiting oneââ¬â¢s view, as in focusing on a building rather than God himself, would hinder oneââ¬â¢s ability to see God. Dickinson goes on to clarify, succinctly, her feelings on the worshiping of God through churches: ââ¬Å"His house was notââ¬âno sign had He / By Chimneyââ¬ânor by Door / Could I infer his Residenceââ¬â / Vast Prairies of Airâ⬠Dickinson tells the reader that nothing tangible or built by the hand of man has been seen by God as His house. Dickenson contends that there is a separation between ââ¬Å"praying and ââ¬Å"worshippingâ⬠. The churches used by the people around Dickinson are used to ââ¬Å"worshipâ⬠and show the action of belief. Whereas praying is the only way to ââ¬Å"reachâ⬠God and prove oneââ¬â¢s heart as a believer. In the poem numbered 1499, Dickinson again questions the physical place worship by calling insecure the ââ¬Å"Physiognomyâ⬠of the Calvinist theology. Dickinson begins this poem by acknowledging the temporality of the human visage: ââ¬Å"How firm Eternity must look / To Crumbling menâ⬠. Dickinson obviously feels that the ââ¬Å"face valueâ⬠of religion is passing and worthless. She felt that the eternality of action and the long lasting effects of true faith were far more important and worth while. The questions raised by Emily Dickenson within her poetry, echoes the problems that people have had with religion for agesââ¬âwhere does the truth about God reside? Dickenson wanted to find a peace that accompanied the acceptance of God; however her exposure to the Calvinist Puritans stifled that. Her distain and mistrust from the sect resounded throughout her life and her poetry. Though not all of her poetry maintained such as hard line rejection of Puritan ideals, the ones selected here illustrate her desire to find something else, outside of the Calvinist dogma that better explained to her the nature of God. It has been ââ¬Å"suggested that [the] contradictions in Emily Dickinson [ââ¬Ës poetry] were due to her dual nature, which made her at once a pagan and a ââ¬Å"sincerely religious woman. â⬠(Voigt 193) This constant pull within her life, caused Dickinson to struggle throughout her lifetime with her desire to loved by God, and her inability to accept the blind faith that accompanies devotion to religion. The several poems that I am looking at are examples of how Emily Dickinsonââ¬â¢s lack of center and acceptance manifested itself into poetry. In poem numbered 315, for example, the fumbling of the unnamed ââ¬Å"heâ⬠at the soul of the narrator is immediately seen as the ultimate of personal invasions. The hap-hazard bumbling of this ââ¬Å"heâ⬠is made worse by the ââ¬Å"stun[ning]â⬠that is caused by this invasion. The different degrees of this stunned soul hints at the multiple levels of invasion that is taking placeââ¬âemotional, physical and, presumably, spiritual. The objectifying human ââ¬Å"Natureâ⬠as brittle is an obvious tool to illustrate the suffering that humanity is plagued with throughout their lives. It also brings in the idea of death and mortality to the concept of human existence. The ââ¬Å"heâ⬠deals the final blow the brittle human narrator with ââ¬Å"One ââ¬â Imperial ââ¬â Thunderboltâ⬠(315. 11) This assumed death, however, does not promise an escape from the constant suffering of life, but instead we learn that ââ¬Å"The Universe ââ¬â is still ââ¬âââ¬Å" (315. 12) The final dash after ââ¬Å"stillâ⬠tells the reader that the universe is still moving, turning, and continuing the pain that the narrator wishes to be freed from. The Civil War was another issue that was addressed by Dickinson. With the poem, ââ¬Å"The name ââ¬â of it ââ¬â is ââ¬ËAutumnââ¬â¢Ã¢â¬ , Dickinson uses natural imagery to describe the horrors of war. David Cody wrote, in his article on the poem, that Dickinsonââ¬â¢s poem continues both to beckon and to baffle its readers, and the present essay is devoted not so much to an attempt to ââ¬Å"guessâ⬠its meaning as to the more modest task of recalling or reviving, palingenetically as it were, some faint ghost or echo at least of the rich, complex and increasingly remote cultural moment in which it came into being. Precisely because it seems to embody. (Cody 24) Ed Folsom wrote that her poem, numbered 754 ââ¬Å"My Life has stood ââ¬â a loaded gunâ⬠; ââ¬Å"explicitly with the Master/slave relationshipâ⬠. (Folsom) The poem identifies with the slaveââ¬â¢s reality of being worthless until pressed into service by the master. The work that Dickinson did during her lifetime was as diversely inspired as it was cryptic. However, the subjects that were covered by her work still hold enough interest and importance to warrant a continued study. The questions that Dickinson raised about religion, echoed the questions of many people who were slowly becoming disenfranchised with the Calvinist movement. Her own issues with psychosis were also subject to her eye. The poems she wrote about her lack of understanding of the world, and the fear that kept her secluded from society offer a deep insight into her mind. WORK CITED The Complete Poems of Emily Dickenson. Johnson, Thomas H. Ed. Little Brown and Co. New York. 1961. The Inner Life of Emily Dickinson. Voigt, Gilbert P. College English. Vol. 3. No. 2. (Nov. 1941). 192-196. The Life of Emily Dickinson. Sewell, Richard Benson. Harvard University Press. Cambridge, MA. 1994. Emily Dickinson: Selected Letters, ed. by Thomas H. Johnson and Theodora Ward. Cambridge MA. Harvard University Press. 1958. Cody, David ââ¬Å"Blood in the Basin: The Civil War in Emily Dickinson ââ¬Å"The name of it is Autumn ââ¬Å"â⬠The Emily Dickinson Journal. The Johns Hopkins University Press. Volume 12, Number 1, Spring 2003, pp. 25-52 Folsom, Ed. ââ¬Å"Walt Whitman, Emily Dickinson, and the Civil Warâ⬠. University of Iowa. 2003. Date of Access: July 26, 2006. URL: http://www. classroomelectric. org/volume2/folsom/
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment